By Jonathan Ekhator and Patrick England
Benedict Emori is a community-led total sanitation (CLTS) champion from Abi Local Government Area (LGA), located in Nigeria’s south-eastern Cross River State. He is participating in the Rural Sanitation and Hygiene Promotion in Nigeria (RUSHPIN) programme, implemented by Concern Universal and funded by the Global Sanitation Fund (GSF) and the Nigerian government. Since 2012, several communities, including Benedict’s, have been embroiled in intermittent land disputes. While these small clashes pale in comparison to the Boko Haram insurgency in Nigeria’s northeast, the conflict in Abi has caused significant local displacements, resettlements, and a perpetual climate of insecurity.
Improving sanitation coverage and hygiene practices through CLTS is especially urgent for populations affected by conflict, which are often the most vulnerable to outbreaks of deadly diseases such as diarrhoea, dysentery and cholera. However, conducting CLTS in insecure environments poses numerous challenges, such as accessing conflict affected communities and ensuring staff security. Even if these communities can be engaged, the CLTS facilitation process is often done under a climate of considerable tension, thereby weakening community-wide action towards ending open defecation. Also, as communities shift their priorities towards security issues, female headed households, the elderly, and people living with disabilities and HIV/AIDs are often those left without the support needed to build basic latrines.
Throughout the RUSHPIN programme, the CLTS process has facilitated the emergence of community support systems, usually involving youth groups, which construct simple toilets for disadvantaged people. When conflict affected communities in Abi were visited by RUSHPIN facilitators, however, youths in the community complained that security, rather than building toilets, was their priority. As Benedict explains, “When we started this work, the initial response was slow. This was primarily because the young men did not buy into it. Many of them were not even at the ‘triggering’ event as they were on guard in the bush as vigilantes.” As a result, open defecation continued, especially for disadvantaged people who lacked the physical and economic means to construct their own latrines.
Despite the intense security situation in Abi, natural leaders such as Benedict do not only act as CLTS champions for their own communities, but also for their neighbours. Benedict is from Emikwor – the first open defecation free (ODF)-certified community in Abi, and his enthusiasm for promoting sanitation and hygiene in his own community quickly caught the attention of the RUSHPIN team. After taking part in a training workshop by Dr Kamal Kar and the CLTS Foundation, Benedict was inspired to take action to help other conflict-affected communities eliminate open defecation: “When I came back, I encouraged other natural leaders like myself to form a group of community consultants to support neighbouring communities to become ODF and dig latrines for disadvantaged households.”
Benedict leads a six person ‘CLTS consultancy’ team from ODF communities that support over 40 other natural leaders from 21 communities, most of whom have been affected by rising insecurity. The team is widely recognized throughout these communities where they sensitize communities on improving sanitation and hygiene, facilitate meetings with traditional leaders and youth groups to close their open defecation areas, and provide practical advice on using locally available materials for simple latrines and handwashing stations. Benedict also says that he uses his own community’s experience to encourage his neighbours. Since then, Emikwor has become a ‘CLTS pilgrimage’ for those who want to learn about achieving ODF status in their own communities.
To address the sanitation access gap for disadvantaged people, Benedict’s team works with enthusiastic youths to build latrines for those who cannot build their own. So far, they have provided 16 simple toilets for widows and elderly people, enabling four conflict-affected communities to eliminate open defecation. Benedict is happy to report his team’s success: “We are making progress. The cleanliness of some of the communities is motivating others to clean up theirs too.”
Insecurity poses significant challenges to the CLTS process. This is especially true for disadvantaged people who can no longer leverage community support systems to provide sanitation facilities. But, as Benedict and his team of CLTS consultants demonstrate, identifying and supporting natural leaders can provide vital support and encouragement for communities struggling with insecurity to achieve full sanitation coverage. Benedict hopes to turn his network of CLTS champions into a community-based organization that works alongside other natural leaders across Abi in order to help their communities eliminate open defecation. In the meantime, Benedict and his team continue to strive to make Abi the first ODF LGA in Cross River State: “No doubt that we are still meeting a lot of resistance from people, but with the enthusiasm of my team, the support from the LGA WASH unit and Concern Universal, I know we will succeed.”
When WASH practitioners understand the patterns and causes of slippage, they can devise innovative strategies to avoid it.
Global Sanitation Fund programmes are designed to incorporate gender considerations and equity dimensions.
Monitoring slippage should go beyond the numbers to truly understand behaviour change and community dynamics.